Spotify Discover Weekly Not Updating, Elsword Zero Private Server, Knox Council Granny Flat, Why Facts Don T Change Our Minds Course Hero, Septic Tank Requirements In Texas, Articles S

Scipio's men quickly abandoned him for Sulla; finding him almost alone in his camp, Sulla tried again to persuade Scipio to defect. The Senate immediately sent an embassy demanding an explanation for his seeming march on the fatherland, to which Sulla responded boldly, saying that he was freeing it from tyrants. To this end, he reaffirmed the requirement that any individual wait for 10 years before being re-elected to any office. [118], For 82BC, the consular elections returned Gnaeus Papirius Carbo, in his third consulship, with the younger Gaius Marius, the son of the seven-time consul, who was then twenty-six. [109] When Flaccus' consular army marched through Macedonia towards Thrace, his command was usurped by his legate Gaius Flavius Fimbria, who had Flaccus killed before chasing Mithridates with his army into Asia itself. Although he was able to regain the command, his political setup in Rome collapsed almost as soon as he left Italy, and the war would . Primary sources are the evidence of history, original records or objects created by participants or observers at the time historical . An example of the extent of his charming side was that his soldiers would sing a ditty about Sulla's one testicle, although without truth, to which he allowed as being "fond of a jest. [107], In the aftermath of the battle, Sulla was approached by Archelaus for terms. Primary sources are first-hand evidence related to the time or event you are investigating.This includes accounts by participants or observers and a wide range of written, physical, audio or visual materials created at the time or later by someone with direct experience.. The dictator is the subject of four Italian operas, two of which take considerable liberties with history: Sulla is a central character in the first three, Lucius Cornelius Sulla is also a character in the first book of the, His first wife was Ilia, according to Plutarch. [19] Plutarch mentions that during his last marriage to Valeria, he still kept company with "actresses, musicians, and dancers, drinking with them on couches night and day.[20]. Making of America. Due to his meeting the minimum age requirement of thirty, he stood for the quaestorship in 108BC. Weekly Newspaper Articles as Primary Sources. To make primary texts readily available for classroom use, they selected important . Primary sources can include: Texts of laws and other original documents. [21] Regardless, by the standards of the Roman political class, Sulla was a very poor man. They had, however, fallen on hard times. His enemy, Lucius Cornelius Cinna, was elected consul for 87BC in place of his candidate;[83] his nephew was rejected as plebeian tribune while Marius' nephew was successful. His third wife was Cloelia, whom Sulla divorced due to sterility. Gaius Sallustius Crispus (Sallust) was born Amiternum in the country of the Sabines in 86 BC. aking of America (MoA) is a digital library of primary sources in American social history from the antebellum period through reconstruction. However, his candidature was dealt a blow when he was brought up on charges of extorting Ariobarzanes. They were, however, successful in holding Macedonia, then governed by propraetor Gaius Sentius and his legate Quintus Bruttius Sura. Encyclopaedia Romana - Has essays on several aspects of ancient Rome. Published by at 29, 2022. Helping or sheltering a proscribed person was punishable by death, while killing a proscribed person was rewarded with two talents. was the first man to use the army to establish a personal autocracy at Rome.. Sulla first came into prominence when he served as quaestor (107-106 B.C.) Late in the year, Sulla cooperated with Marius (who was a legate in the northern theatre) in the northern part of southern Italy to defeat the Marsi: Marius defeated the Marsi, sending them headlong into Sulla's waiting forces. Primary Sources are immediate, first-hand accounts of a topic, from people who had a direct connection with it. Lucius Cornelius Sulla Felix[8] (/sl/; 13878 BC), commonly known as Sulla, was a Roman general and statesman. Textbook passages discussing specific concepts, events, and experiments. [32] After the Senate approved negotiations with Bocchus, it delegated the talks to Marius, who appointed Sulla as envoy plenipotentiary. From 133BC and the start of Tiberius Gracchus' land reforms, Italian communities were displaced from de jure Roman public lands over which no title had been enforced for generations. Finding Primary Sources Primary Sources from DocsTeach Thousands of online primary source documents from the National Archives to bring the past to life as classroom teaching tools. Primary sources are original . [56] When the pro-Italian plebeian tribune Marcus Livius Drusus was assassinated in 91BC while trying again to pass a bill extending Roman citizenship, the Italians revolted. [127] Sulla himself was defeated and forced to flee into his camp, but his lieutenant Crassus on the right wing won the battle in the night. onwards. Primary source is a term used in a number of disciplines to describe source material that is closest to the person, information, period, or idea being studied. Despite initial difficulties, Sulla was successful with minimal resources and preparation; with few Roman troops, he hastily levied allied soldiers and advanced quickly into rugged terrain before routing superior enemy forces. However, if you were studying how compact fluorescent light bulbs are presented in the popular media, the magazine article could be considered a primary source. [110], After peace was reached, Sulla advanced on Fimbria's forces, which deserted their upstart commander. [44], His term as praetor was largely uneventful, excepting a public dispute with Gaius Julius Caesar Strabo (possibly his brother-in-law) and his magnificent holding of the ludi Apollinares. Killing Cluentius before the city's walls, Sulla then invested the town and for his efforts was awarded a grass crown, the highest Roman military honour. During these times on the stage, after initially only singing, he started writing plays, Atellan farces, a kind of crude comedy. Marius and Sulla are very curious figures in the late Roman Republic. Sulla's career is recounted in detail in Howard Hayes Scullard, From the Gracchi to Nero: A History of Rome from 133 B.C. The proceeds from auctioned property more than made up for the cost of rewarding those who killed the proscribed, filling the treasury. Primary sources are most often produced around the time of the events you are studying. [100] The Pontic casualties given in Plutarch and Appian, the main sources for the battles, are exaggerated; Sulla's report that he suffered merely fifteen losses is not credible. These two reforms were enacted primarily to allow Sulla to increase the size of the Senate from 300 to 600 senators. [105] Sulla moved to intercept Flaccus' army in Thessaly, but turned around when Pontic forces reoccupied Boetia. Eyeglasses from Colonial America would be a primary source about Early American History. His troops prepared the ground by starting to dig a series of three trenches, which successfully contained Pontic cavalry. [141][140][142][143][144] Accounts were also written that he had an infestation of worms, caused by the ulcers, which led to his death. [17] After his father's death, around the time Sulla reached adulthood, Sulla found himself impoverished. His execution in AD 62 on the orders of emperor Nero made him the last of the Cornelii Sullae. The Acropolis was then besieged. After some days, both sides engaged in battle. [28][29], Under Marius, the Roman forces followed a very similar plan as under Metellus, capturing and garrisoning fortified positions in the African countryside. [84] Cinna, even before the election, said he would prosecute Sulla at the conclusion of the latter's consular term. primary name: Sulla, Lucius Cornelius other name: Cornelius L f P n Sulla Felix . This may have been related to Sulla's campaign for the consulship. Some of these historians lived at the time of the events, and therefore, may actually be primary sources, but others, especially Plutarch (CE 45-125), who covers men from multiple eras, lived later than the events they describe. [104] When the Pontic cavalry attacked to interrupt the earthworks, the Romans almost broke; Sulla personally rallied his men on foot and stabilised the area. The veto power of the tribunes and their legislating authority were soon reinstated, ironically during the consulships of Pompey and Crassus.[150]. When it came to hiding his intentions, his mind was incredibly unfathomable, yet with all else he was extremely generous; especially with money. However, despite this portrayal, particularly from Plutarch's accounts, it is difficult to determine just how culpable Marius and Sulla were for the chaos that engulfed the Roman Republic They are different from secondary sources, accounts that retell, analyze, or interpret events, usually at a distance of time or place." Library of Congress Teacher's Page. By. Proscribing or outlawing every one of those whom he perceived to have acted against the best interests of the Republic while he was in the east, Sulla ordered some 1,500 nobles (i.e. "[132] The majority of the proscribed had not been enemies of Sulla, but instead were killed for their property, which was confiscated and auctioned off. J. Find these with these special Subject terms. This, along with the increase in the number of courts, further added to the power that was already held by the senators. Wikipedia entry + Cornelius , Epaphroditus , Sylla 138/31 The birth of L.Sulla. [45][46], While governing Cilicia, Sulla received orders from the Senate to restore Ariobarzanes to the throne of Cappadocia. Sulla was closely associated with Venus,[9] adopting the title Epaphroditos meaning favored of Aphrodite/Venus.[10]. [citation needed], Sulla became embroiled in a political fight against one of the plebeian tribunes, Publius Sulpicius Rufus, on the matter of how the new Italian citizens were to be distributed into the Roman tribes for purposes of voting. [34] The publicity attracted by this feat boosted Sulla's political career. [93] News of these conquests reached Rome in the autumn of 89BC, leading the Senate and people to declare war; actual preparations for war were, however, delayed: after Sulla was given the command, it took him some eighteen months to organise five legions before setting off; Rome was also severely strained financially. From this distance, Sulla remained out of the day-to-day political activities in Rome, intervening only a few times when his policies were involved (e.g. [113] The extra time spent in Asia, moreover, equipped him with forces and money later put to good use in Italy. Primary sources are "first-hand" information, sources as close as possible to the origin of the information or idea under study. The later battle, at Orchomenus, was fought in high summer but before the start of the autumn rains. According only to Appian, he then brought legislation to strengthen the Senate's position in the state and weaken the plebeian tribunes by eliminating the comitia tributa as a legislative body and requiring that tribunes first receive senatorial approval for legislation;[80] some scholars, however, reject Appian's account as mere retrojection of legislation passed during Sulla's dictatorship. In 109, Rome sent Quintus Caecilius Metellus to continue the war. The cultivated grapevine (Vitis vinifera ssp. [49] At this meeting, Sulla was told by a Chaldean seer that he would die at the height of his fame and fortune. Primary sources in history are often created by people who witnessed, participated in, or were otherwise close to a particular event. In the sciences and social sciences, primary sources or 'primary research' are original research experiments, studies, or . Updated on June 22, 2022 Students. [117] Sulla attempted to open negotiations with Norbanus, who was at Capua, but Norbanus refused to treat and withdrew to Praeneste as Sulla advanced. [146] An epitaph, which Sulla composed himself, was inscribed onto the tomb, reading, "No friend ever served me, and no enemy ever wronged me, whom I have not repaid in full. Catulus, with Sulla, moved to block their advance; the two men likely cooperated well. Sulla had the distinction of holding the office of consul twice, as well as reviving the dictatorship. Sulla then duly besieged the city. This prophecy was to have a powerful hold on Sulla throughout his lifetime. Washington, DC, March 19, 2013 - The U.S. invasion of Iraq turned out to be a textbook case of flawed assumptions, wrong-headed intelligence, propaganda manipulation, and administrative ad hockery, according to the National Security Archive's briefing book of declassified documents posted today to mark the 10 th anniversary of the war. Sulla was born in a very turbulent era of Rome's history, which has often been described as the beginning of the fall of the Roman Republic.The political climate was marked by civil discord and rampant political violence where voting in the Assembly was . Learning in Black and White. [64], Political developments in Rome also started to bring an end to the war. Cornelius Lucius Sulla; Lucius Cornelius Cinna (elder) Marcus Licinius Crassus; Pompey the Great (Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus) Julius Caesar; Marcus . Sulla's First Civil War (88-87 BC) was triggered by an attempt to strip him of the command against Mithridates and saw Sulla become the first Roman to lead an army against the city for four hundred years. The Senate moved the senatus consultum ultimum against him and was successful in levying large amount of men and materiel from the Italians. [100], In the summer of 86BC, two major battles were fought in Boeotia. Sulla's arrival in Brundisium induced defections from the Senate in Rome: Marcus Licinius Crassus, who had already fled from the Cinnan regime, raised an army in Spain, and departed for Africa to join with Metellus Pius (who also joined the Sullans), joined Sulla even before his landing in Italy. Marius, an Italian by birth rather than a pure Roman, was a relative newcomer to the Roman elite, and he was considered an outsider by the Senate fathers. National Library Services to Schools has developed a suite of primary source analysis tools specifically for Aotearoa New Zealand schools. Historian Suetonius records that when agreeing to spare Caesar, Sulla warned those who were pleading his case that he would become a danger to them in the future, saying, "In this Caesar, there are many Mariuses. Tools for primary source analysis. (5) Horace, Epode (c. 35 BC) Sulla and Pompeius Rufus opposed the bill, which Sulpicius took as a betrayal; Sulpicius, without the support of the consuls, looked elsewhere for political allies. These sources have not been modified by interpretation and offer original thought or new information. The Battle of Sacriportus occurred between the forces of Young Marius and the battle-hardened legions of Sulla. [31] Ultimately, the Numidians were defeated in 106BC, due in large part to Sulla's initiative in capturing the Numidian king. These sieges lasted until spring of 86BC. Marius was elected consul and, through assignment by tribunician legislation, took over the campaign. [61] Pompeii was taken some time during the year, along with Stabiae and Aeclanum; with the capture of Aeclanum, Sulla forced the Hirpini to surrender. Taking Action: Benefits for students that extend beyond the classroom. You can use the following terms to search HOLLIS for primary sources:. [24] Keaveney 2005, pp. Ideally, each ensemble is diverse, both in cultural background and practical experience. [17], One story, "as false as it is charming", relates that when Sulla was a baby, his nurse was carrying him around the streets, until a strange woman walked up to her and said, "Puer tibi et reipublicae tuae felix", which can be translated as, "The boy will be a source of luck to you and your state". Copyright statement. Sulla rose to prominence during the war against the Numidian king Jugurtha, whom he captured as a result of Jugurtha's betrayal by the king's allies, although his superior Gaius Marius took credit for ending the war. [18] Lacking ready money, Sulla spent his youth among Romes comedians, actors, lute players, and dancers. At the same time, the younger Marius sent word to assemble the Senate and purge it of suspected Sullan sympathisers: the urban praetor Lucius Junius Brutus Damasippus then had four prominent men killed at the ensuing meeting. Deciding whether a source is primary or secondary is sometimes confusing. His family was patrician, part of the ruling class in ancient Rome. He might have been disinherited, though it was "more likely" that his father simply had nothing to bequeath. Sulla, himself a patrician, thus ineligible for election to the office of Plebeian Tribune, thoroughly disliked the office. Beyond personal enmity, Caesar Strabo may also have stood for office because it was evident that Rome's relations with the Pontic king, Mithridates VI Eupator, were deteriorating and that the consuls of 88 would be assigned an extremely lucrative and glorious command against Pontus. [90] By the end of 87BC, Cinna and Marius had besieged Rome and taken the city, killed consul Gnaeus Octavius, massacred their political enemies, and declared Sulla an outlaw; they then had themselves elected consuls for 86BC. Marius arranged for Sulla to lift the iustitium and allow Sulpicius to bring proposals; Sulla, in a "desperately weak position [received] little in return[,] perhaps no more than a promise that Sulla's life would be safe". Primary sources provide raw information and first-hand evidence. The first of the, Pages displaying wikidata descriptions as a fallback, sfn error: no target: CITEREFBadian2012 (. Primary Source Terms:. Also, Faustus Cornelius Sulla, Nero's cousin, was exiled as a potential rival in 58. Speeches, diaries, letters and interviews - what the people involved said or . Primary sources include historical and legal documents, eyewitness accounts, results of experiments, statistical data, pieces of creative writing, and art objects. What Is a Primary Source? Examples of tertiary sources include encyclopedias and dictionaries, chronologies, almanacs, directories, indexes, and bibliographies. Sulla played an important role in the long political struggle between the optimates and populares factions at Rome. Social: Facebook Page YouTube Page Instagram Page. "[148][149] Sulla's example proved that it could be done, therefore inspiring others to attempt it; in this respect, he has been seen as another step in the Republic's fall. A research article or study proving this would be a primary source. As such, he sought to strengthen the aristocracy, and thus the Senate. Years later, in 91BC, Bocchus paid for the erection of gilded equestrian statue depicting Sulla's capture of Jugurtha. [87], Sulla's ability to use military force against his own countrymen was "in many ways a continuation of the Social War a civil war between former allies and friends developed into a civil war between citizens what was eroded in the process was the fundamental distinction between Romans and foreign enemies". [47], Sulla's campaign in Cappadocia had led him to the banks of the Euphrates, where he was approached by an embassy from the Parthian Empire. Cinna violently quarrelled with his co-consul, Gnaeus Octavius. Sulla then served as legate under his former commander and, in that stead, successfully subdued a Gallic tribe which revolted in the aftermath of a previous Roman defeat. Books. The breakdown allowed Sulla to play the aggrieved party and place blame on his enemies for any further bloodshed. Newspaper reports, by reporters who witnessed an event or who quote people who did. For now, Cinna and the Marian political faction would have to wait, but revenge would prove far deadlier than anything that had come before it. Book Sources: Bloody Sunday - Selma to Montgomery March (1965) A selection of books/e-books available in Trible Library. Primary sources are available here primarily for use in high-school and university/college courses. If you have questions, please consult your instructor or librarian. He was awarded the Grass Crown for his bravery at the Battle of Nola. The young Gaius Julius Caesar, as Cinna's son-in-law, became one of Sulla's targets, and fled the city. Campaigning on his military record, the people were unwilling to hear tales of military bravado from a mere junior officer after two triumphs. Primary sources are documents, images, relics, or other works that provide firsthand details of a historical or scientific event. Sulla had his enemies declared hostes, probably from outside the pomerium, and after assembling an assembly where he apologised for the ongoing war, left to fight Carbo in Etruria. Resigning his dictatorship in 79 BC, Sulla retired to private life and died the following year. [38] The next year, Sulla was elected military tribune and served under Marius,[39] and assigned to treat with the Marsi, part of the Germanic invaders, he was able to negotiate their defection from the Cimbri and Teutones. He was, however, defeated. [152], Sulla was red-blond[154] and blue-eyed, and had a dead-white face covered with red marks. A gifted and innovative general, he achieved numerous successes in wars against foreign and domestic opponents. Archelaus tried to break out but were unsuccessful; Sulla then annihilated the Pontic army and captured its camp. The allies in central and southern Italy had fought side by side with Rome in several wars and had grown restive under Roman autocratic rule, wanting instead Roman citizenship and the privileges it conferred. In fact, many sources can be either primary or secondary depending on the context of the research and of the source itself. Examples include interview transcripts, statistical data, and works of art. Marius, offering his services to Cinna, helped levy troops. [30] Sulla was popular with the men, charming and benign, he built up a healthy rapport while also winning popularity with other officers, including Marius. Biographies of historical and famous people. Upon his arrival, Sulla had his quaestor Lucullus order Sura, who had vitally delayed Mithridates' advances into Greece, to retreat back into Macedonia. Websites. The Samnite and anti-Sullan commanders were then hunted down as "for all intents and purposes the civil war in Italy was over". The hundreds of thousands of men who enlisted . They are the most direct evidence of a time or event because they were created by people or things that were there at the time or event. His son, Faustus Cornelius Sulla, issued denarii bearing the name of the dictator,[151] as did a grandson, Quintus Pompeius Rufus. He then fought successfully against Germanic tribes during the Cimbrian War, and Italian allies during the Social War. [115] Sulla, buoyed by his previous looting in Asia, was able to advance quickly and largely without the ransacking of the Italian countryside. He never allowed his debaucheries to interfere with his duties but he devoted all his leisure time to them. Secondary Sources: Primary sources are not complete; you will find the following helpful: Boardman, John, ed. 1011 accepts these inheritances without much comment and places them around Sulla's turning thirty years of age. [73] The consuls, fearful of intimidation of Sulpicius and his armed bodyguards, declared a suspension of public business (iustitium) which led to Sulpicius and his mob forcing the consuls to flee. His rival, Gnaeus Papirius Carbo, described Sulla as having the cunning of a fox and the courage of a lion but that it was his cunning that was by far the most dangerous. Primary research gives you direct access to the subject of your research. Lucius Cornelius Sulla was born in 138 BCE in Puteoli, Italy. He became a tribune of the plebeians in 52 BC where he gained a reputation for being a strong supporter of the populares. Sulla is generally seen as having set the precedent for Caesar's march on Rome and dictatorship. To further solidify the prestige and authority of the Senate, Sulla transferred the control of the courts from the equites, who had held control since the Gracchi reforms, to the senators. Possibly to protect himself from future political retribution, Sulla had the sons and grandsons of the proscribed banned from running for political office, a restriction not removed for over 30 years. 82 BC. The law was vetoed by one of the tribunes, but when Quintus Pompeius Rufus went to Pompey Strabo's army to take command under the Senate's authority, he was promptly assassinated after his arrival and assumption of command, almost certainly on Strabo's orders. [2023] Welcome to The Internet History Sourcebooks Project, a collection of public domain and copy-permitted historical texts presented cleanly (without advertising or excessive layout) for educational use. This "firsthand" understanding of human motivations and the ordinary Roman citizen may explain why he was able to succeed as a general despite lacking any significant military experience before his 30s.[25]. [11], Sulla, the son of Lucius Cornelius Sulla and the grandson of Publius Cornelius Sulla,[12] was born into a branch of the patrician gens Cornelia, but his family had fallen to an impoverished condition at the time of his birth. [125], Carbo, who had suffered defeats by Metellus Pius and Pompey, attempted to redeploy so to relieve his co-consul Marius at Praeneste. Newspapers. Sulla would ratify Mithridates' position in Pontus and have him declared a Roman ally. 101 BC: Took part in the defeat of the Cimbri at the, 90-89 BC: Senior officer in the Social War, as, Holds the consulship for the first time, with, 87 BC: Commands Roman armies to fight King, 85 BC: Liberates the provinces of Macedonia, Asia, and Cilicia from Pontic occupation, 83 BC: Returns to Italy and undertakes civil war against the factional Marian government, 83-82 BC: Enters war with the followers of Gaius Marius the Younger and Cinna, 82 BC: Obtains victory at the battle of the Colline Gate, 80 BC: Holds the consulship for the second time. With the capture and execution of Carbo, who had fled Sicily for Egypt, both consuls for 82BC were now dead. Wikipedia entry. Ozzy Osbourne Grandchildren, Dalton Smith Pogo Stick, Best Basketball Camps In Ontario, Rinnai R53i Parts Diagram, Mennonite Vs Amish Vs Mormon, He could acknowledge the law as valid. [33] Winning Bocchus' friendship and making plain Rome's demands for Jugurtha's deliverance, Sulla successfully concluded negotiations and secured Bocchus' capture of Jugurtha and the king's rendition to Marius' camp. [68] Shortly after Sulla's election, probably in the last weeks of the year, Sulla married his daughter to one of his colleague Pompeius Rufus' sons. Historians and other scholars classify sources as primary or secondary. He brought Pompeii under siege. [35], In 104BC, the Cimbri and the Teutones, two Germanic tribes who had bested the Roman legions on several occasions, seemed to again be heading for Italy. In this first video of a 2-part tutorial, we will discuss primary sources. [116] Advancing on Capua, he met the two consuls of that year Lucius Cornelius Scipio Asiaticus and Gaius Norbanus who had dangerously divided their forces. porterville unified school district human resources; Tags . He had close connections to the imperial family and was the husband of Antonia, Claudius's daughter, and might thus have been seen as a threat to Nero. As a result, "husbands were butchered in the arms of their wives, sons in the arms of their mothers. [113], Sulla crossed the Adriatic for Brundisium in spring of 83BC with five legions of Mithridatic veterans, capturing Brundisium without a fight. [70][71] They were designed to regulate Rome's finances, which were in a very sorry state after all the years of continual warfare. On each line there is a link to the page where the name can be found. He won the first large-scale civil war in Roman history and became the first man of the Republic to seize power through force. During these marriages, he engaged in an affair with Nicopolis, who also was older than him. sulla primary sources. [66] Buttressed by success against Rome's traditional enemies, the Samnites, and general Roman victory across Italy, Sulla stood for and was elected easily to the consulship of 88BC; his colleague would be Quintus Pompeius Rufus. Se l'azienda ha pi di 200 dipendenti, deve essere presente anche il rappresentante sindacale aziendale (RSA). Perseus Collection of Greek and Roman Material - Has numerous texts of primary sources. [126] Sulla's specific movements are very vaguely described in Appian, but he was successful in preventing the Italians from relieving Praeneste or joining with Carbo. Through Sulla's reforms to the Plebeian Council, tribunes lost the power to initiate legislation. In the ensuing fight, Sulla defeated Marius, who consequently fled to Praeneste. This, of course, made him very popular with the poorer citizens. Pompey, the son of Pompey Strabo, raised a legion from his clients in Picenum and also joined Sulla; Sulla treated him with great respect and addressed him as imperator before dispatching him to raise more troops. At the start of his second consulship in 80BC with Metellus Pius, Sulla resigned his dictatorship. Finally, in a demonstration of his absolute power, Sulla expanded the Pomerium, the sacred boundary of Rome, unchanged since the time of the kings. [81.3] Magnesia, the only city in Asia that remained loyal, was defended against Mithridates with the greatest courage.